CNET Community Hot Topics weekly newsletter
January 30, 2007
Dear CNET members,
Finally, the long-awaited Windows Vista is here! And whether you are a Microsoft fan or not, you probably can't help but hear the buzz on Vista. It's been five years since the launch of XP, and people are looking forward to big changes for Windows. But the question for everyday home users is, is there much change at all? Or are we talking about a very expensive service pack upgrade for Windows XP? According to Microsoft, one of the reasons to upgrade to Vista is that it is suppose to be more secure, but according to the latest CNET Security Watch column: "That $200 Windows XP service pack called Vista", Senior Editor Robert Vamosi points out that "most of the touted security enhancements in Windows Vista don't appear in the Home Premium and Basic versions, and what is there, what's not already available within Windows XP, could have fit into a free Windows XP service pack instead of requiring a $200 upgrade." Now that's one expensive service pack! So does that mean we're paying a couple of hundred bucks for something a little prettier, maybe a bit easier to use, but you still have to tightly manage security on your own? Personally, I say "no, thanks," at least to the home or basic versions. So what do you think? Do you agree with Rob's column? Why or why not? Read his article and get talking--because we want to know exactly what's on your mind about Vista.

Cheers!
Lee Koo
Manager, CNET community


Got suggestions? Send us an e-mail:
messageboards@cnet.com
This week's hot topic:
Vista Home Premium and Basic versions just a $200 service pack?
In his latest Security Watch column, Senior Editor Robert Vamosi summarizes that most of the touted security enhancements in Windows Vista don't appear in the Home Premium and Basic versions of Vista. And they simply could have fit those into a free Windows XP Service Pack instead. Do you agree or disagree? Many of you chimed in to tell us what you thought.

"It's all about money!"
"I'm sure MS is coming up with XP service packs and figuring they're not getting any money out of it or any other updates and/or patches, so why not just coat the SPs / patches / updates... with some graphic/cosmetic upgrades and call it a new OS? It's like throwing a new coat of paint..." (Read more)
--Submitted by: CNET member OneIJack
"Do you honestly think all this will matter?"
"I am reading the latest about Windows Vista. I remember the Windows ME issue...Same ol' thing, just prettier. Then the problems started. We run Netware, and Novell and MS are having a pissing contest over SLED 10, so no Netware Drivers for Vista. We used to get those with Windows 95/98..." (Read more)
--Submitted by: CNET member Zorched
"Make me proud to be a PC user!!"
"I am reading the latest about Windows Vista. I remember the Windows ME issue...Same ol' thing, just prettier. Then the problems started. We run Netware, and Novell and MS are having a pissing contest over SLED 10, so no Netware Drivers for Vista. We used to get those with Windows 95/98..." (Read more)
--Submitted by: CNET member efh777
Speak Up!
Want to weigh in on the Windows Vista debate? Check out the latest Security Watch column: "That $200 Windows XP service pack called Vista", and tell us if you think the security enhancements within Windows Vista Home Premium and Basic are enough for you to pay $200 to upgrade today?
CNET Windows Vista resources:
Your complete guide to Microsoft
  Windows Vista

  From CNET At Work

Latest Windows Vista news
  From CNET News.com

Windows Vista blogs
  From Crave

Windows Vista downloads
  From CNET Download.com

Vista Readiness Advisor
  From CNET.com

What's in each Vista edition?
  From CNET Reviews

Windows Vista forum
  From CNET forums

Quick Hits
Here are some interesting comments you've recently submitted on CNET. Read up on it and talk about it.

31 megapixels enough for you?
So you think you've got megapixels? Try one of Hasselblad's cameras on for size. A year after releasing the world's first 39-megapixel camera, Hasselblad has introduced a "more affordable" model at 31 megapixels and a shooting rate of 1.2 seconds per image, as well as a bevy of other features.
Is Vista going to be the new Windows Me?
Most of us remember how Windows Me became the least favorite Windows version to date. The changes were deep and bizarre compared to all other Windows at the time, even if we include XP. Why am I suddenly predicting that Vista might be the next Windows Me?


 
Weigh in on this week's hot topic:
Will you be installing Windows Vista on your system this year?
(Please click on button to vote)

 Yes.
 I'm already using it. (How do you like it?)
 After it's been out for a few months.
    (How long will you wait?)
 No way! (Why not?)
 I will buy a new system with it
    already installed.
 I don't even have XP yet!
 I'm on a Mac and will never go to
    the dark side.
 Don't know yet.
Last week's poll results 
Of David Carnoy's seven tech predictions for 2007, which do you think is the most likely to occur?
News.com hot discussions


Hot Products
Along with discussing Windows Vista, CNET members had plenty of new tech products to talk about this week.

Sanyo M1
CNET member Matt -- HB Cali says:
"There are tons of other things to appreciate about this phone like the 2.0 mp camera, space-only limited video capture times (although you have to transfer anything over 500kb(?) Via. The USB cable), superb voice activation controls etc. but this review would never stop if I went on about all of that stuff..." (read more)
See all user opinions | Compare prices

Sony Handycam HDR-SR1
CNET member jpbrunke says:
"This camera was perfect for me. At first I was looking at Sony's DVD-505 because of the burn to DVD. Then I saw the HC3 with the High-def. but I didn't like that I had to buy small DVDs or tapes. When I saw this camcorder and the options that it had, it was perfect..." (read more)
Read all user opinions | Compare prices

Sony KDS-R60XBR2
CNET member bikerunark says:
"I've had this TV for a few weeks and absolutely LOVE it. For HD content, the picture is the best I've seen. Felt like I was in the stands at the World Series (there is NO WAY HD viewers are buying the story that the sticky mess on the pitcher's hand was dirt) and football on ESPNHD is incredible. Friends have been inviting themselves over for Monday night football..." (read more)
Read all user opinions | Compare prices




The e-mail address for your CNET Community newsletter is test.tester@cnet.com. Click here to manage your newsletters, including this one.

If you no longer wish to receive this newsletter, please unsubscribe.

Privacy statement
CNET Networks takes your privacy seriously. Because we gather certain types of information about our users, we want you to clearly understand the terms and conditions surrounding the collection and use of this information. We encourage you to review our privacy policy.

Copyright 2007 CNET Networks, Inc. All rights reserved.
CNET Networks, Inc.
235 Second Street
San Francisco, CA 94105
U.S.A.