CNET
View online  | Share on Facebook
April 10, 2009
Should I go with a digital compact camera or
a dSLR?

Dear CNET members,

Happy Friday! I missed you all! A few of my family members have been out sick these past couple of weeks, and I've been in and out of work attending to their needs, so I was unable to deliver the newsletters to you folks. With that in mind, I hope this newsletter finds everyone in good health! Now let's tackle Cecilia's question on whether she should move on to a digital SLR camera or stick with a compact digital camera.

This week, many members, ranging from beginners to seasoned shutterbugs, came through for Cecilia and shared their expertise, recommendations, and true passion on this topic--we are very fortunate to have you all here to participate. Many of the answers provided by members included a lot of pros and cons for both camera types, from the limitations of the compact camera to the size and cost of dSLRs. Member hjfok even provided us with some links to his photos to show what a camera can and cannot do well, which is awesome. Thanks hjfok!

All in all, as most people mentioned, Cecilia, what you want to achieve with your photos, how far you want to take your photography hobby, and your budget, will determine your tools of the trade. But I will vouch that getting a dSLR can get very expensive, very fast. One thing that I can recommend is to see if you have a local camera shop that will allow you to rent dSLRs and lenses to try out. This way you can really get a good feel for the different types of cameras and see the actual picture quality that can be achieved under different conditions versus a compact digital camera. You'll be able to give it a try and see if it's something you want to get into. This helped me tremendously in my decision making, but I will warn you, though: once you see the unlimited possibilities you can achieve with a dSLR camera, you may never turn back.

So for starters, I picked out a few featured answers in the Q&A area, but I urge you folks to read through all the submissions, as the knowledge and suggestions that our members have passed down to us is invaluable. I know this information will prove helpful to all in need. And as always, if you have any additional information to share, I invite you to join in and tell all. Thank you, everyone!


Cheers!
- Lee


Got suggestions? Send me an e-mail: messageboards@cnet.com

Lee Koo
Lee Koo
CNET Community manager
Last week's question
Should I go with a digital compact camera or a dSLR?
QuestionDear CNET friends, you've shared so much valuable info with us over time that I feel you are really good friends. Thank you! My question is in regards to choosing a digital compact or a digital SLR camera. Finance is an issue though I am willing to save up till I can get what I want. I love taking macro shots but also like using zoom for better bird shots. My present camera is a compact Canon Powershot A620, 7.1 megapixels and 4x zoom. It's been a great camera for me but now that I've learnt more about photography it's time to move on.

I had almost decided to get the best Canon compact with 18x zoom, but a camera salesman told me if I want good (sharp) macro shots I'd be better with a lower price range SLR body and pay extra for a reasonably good macro lens. His opinion is that Canon had added more zoom etc. to their compacts but that the lens was still the same quality. Could someone please advise me for what I need? Many thanks in advance.

-- Submitted by: Cecilia P.

AnswerFeatured member solutions
for last week's question:

 "If you're serious then go for it "
-- Submitted by: kalel33

 "Differences between point-and-shoot and dSLR... "
-- Submitted by: kLevkoff

 "The camera is just a function of what you want to achieve "
-- Submitted by: fschoonbaert

 "Compact vs. dSLR "
-- Submitted by: hjfok

 "Digital SLR vs 'something else'"
-- Submitted by: Watzman

 Read all member contributions

 Thanks to all who contributed!

Previous questions and answers
1. Extending the life of my laptop's battery

2. Help! I'm at my wits end trying to manage my passwords

3. Is it safe to mount a flat screen over my fireplace?

4. Help, I need to make my Windows XP system legit again

5. Do burned CDs and DVDs have a shelf life?

 All previous Community newsletters
Community buzz
1. New laptop, need some recommendations on some safety measures

2. Am I being ripped off?

3. Lower-end HDTV help/buying suggestion

4. How many megapixels needed for large photo blow ups?

5. How to backup system

6. Confused about closed captioning and HDTV

7. In your opinion which BlackBerry phone is the best?

8. UGH...are we becoming a poor audio quality society?

 More from the CNET forums

Mac nugget
1. How to: Reinstall OS X on a new hard drive

2. iMac vs. Mac Pro without spending a lot money

3. iMovie DVD once worked, now not recognized

4. Alienware m17 or MacBook Pro 17 inches (unibody)?

 More from the Mac OS forum
Security alerts and updates
1. How to remove the Downadup and Conficker worm

2. Microsoft security bulletin advance notification for April

3. Virus and spyware alerts - April 10, 2009
4. Updates - April 10, 2009

 More from the security forum
Check out next week's question:
Windows 7, please enlighten me with your opinions on this to be released OS
Next week's questionThis may be a premature questions, but I would to know a bit more about Windows 7. For those who beta tested Windows 7 and/or are still currently running Windows 7, what is your opinion on Windows 7? Is it really better than Vista or worse? If better, how so? Are there more features? What new features can we expect to see? My current system is running Windows Vista, will I have to upgrade my hardware again to run 7? And last question, will you be upgrading to Windows 7 when it is released? Please enlighten me on anything you can for me and others who are curious and anticipating this new OS release. Thank for all your opinions and insights to these questions.

-- Submitted by: Enrique B.

(Please keep this discussion civil. This is not a rant on Microsoft thread. If you have nothing constructive to say, don't post anything at all. Thank you!)

  Know the answer? Click here to submit it!

Have a tech-related question?
Click here to e-mail us on one of these topics:

· PC troubleshooting
· PC upgrading
· Digital music
· Consumer electronics
· Multimedia
· Internet security
· Digital cameras
· Home audio & video

Need help tech right away? Don't wait for us, post your questions in the CNET forums for all the tech help and how-tos.

Quick pollCommunity quick poll
Weigh in on this week poll topic!
How often do you use the viewfinder on your point-and-shoot camera?

(Please click on button to vote)

 Always.
 About half the time.
 Only when I absolutely have to.
 Rarely.
 Never.
 My camera doesn't have a viewfinder
 I don't even remember if I have a viewfinder on my camera.

Vote and discuss it here!
Simple question, simple answer
1. Upgrading from graphics adapter on motherboard to separate video card

2. Hard drive advertised capacity is not what it is, why?

3. Does anyone know of free, or inexpensive photo editing software?
Help your fellow members
1. Cell phone cases: soft of hard?

2. Copy & paste functionality won't work!

3. What's the best laptop cooler?

4. Best, worth the money, wireless iPod speaker system?
Deals and bargains
1. ARP Aquos 42" LC42D65U 1080p for $899

2. Costco members - Acer X223WBD 22" W Monitor 149.99 + 10 shipping

3. Tips on filling out rebate forms

 More from the Deals and Bargains forum

More from the CNET forums
 Windows Vista  Windows XP  Digital cameras
 Desktops  Laptops  MP3 players
 Home audio & video  Spyware, viruses, & security  View all forums



The e-mail address for this newsletter is test.tester@cnet.com. Click here to manage your newsletters, including this one.

If you no longer wish to receive this newsletter, please unsubscribe.

Privacy statement
CNET Networks takes your privacy seriously. Because we gather certain types of information about our users, we want you to clearly understand the terms and conditions surrounding the collection and use of this information. We encourage you to review our privacy policy.



Copyright 2009 CBS Interactive Inc. All rights reserved.
CBS Interactive Inc. 235 Second Street, San Francisco, CA 94105, U.S.A.


CNET