CNET Community Hot Topics weekly newsletter
July 12, 2005
Dear CNET members,
An iPod is one of those things that even if you aren't a music lover or an MP3 player enthusiast, you can't help but hear, see, or read about it. Since its debut in late 2001, with almost four years of buzz and popularity under the iPod's belt, it has gained a massive following. You have iPod lovers, haters, and everyone in between. Considering all the publicity, I'm curious as to where the iPod-vs.-the-others debates will rank in history. So what do you think of the iPod--do you think it is overrated? What makes the iPod so great: brilliance of marketing or brilliance of technology or none of the above? Do you think the iPod will thrive for the next four years, or will it sink to become just another fad? Many community members have already left their two cents in our Make Some Noise forum; now it's your turn to bring on the heat and tell us if you think the iPod is the real deal or just hype.

Cheers!
Lee Koo
Manager, CNET community
Got suggestions? Send us an e-mail:
messageboards@cnet.com
This week's hot topic:
Are iPods overrated?
Is the Apple iPod the greatest MP3 player ever, or is it all a bunch of hype? That's the question we pose in our new Make Some Noise, and many of you offer insightful and passionate opinions.

Pomp and packaging
CNET member yamza says that the iPod is all hype, thanks to the player's slick packaging and hip marketing. He goes on to recommend players from iRiver and Cowon that trump the iPod in features and functionality.
Read yamza's full post

Well worth the hype
Though the iPod might not be the most technically advanced, CNET member hatandglasses13 praises it and iTunes for setting a high industry standard for MP3 players as well as online music retail.
Read hatandglasses13's full post

Just overexposed
Though he's opted to go with a different MP3 player, CNET member fatdogmojo doesn't think the iPod is overrated, just overexposed. The player's overwhelming popularity causes it to take on more scrutiny than other players.
Read fatdogmojo's full post

Speak Up!
Is the iPod is worth its hype? Visit "Make Some Noise", and let us know what you think!
CNET MP3 resources:
Editors' top MP3 players
  From CNET Reviews

CNET Music Center
  From CNET.com

MP3 player buying guide
  From CNET Reviews

MP3 players forum
  From CNET forums

Quick Hits
Here are some interesting comments you've recently submitted on CNET. Read up on it and talk about it.

Which carmaker offers the best quality?
Whether it's Chevy vs. Ford, domestic vs. foreign, or luxury vs. economy, everyone seems to have a pick for highest-quality auto manufacturer. Let your voice be heard!
Why spyware's here to stay (for now)
Who's looking out for your best interests in stopping spyware? If you said the antispyware vendors, you might want to think again. Robert Vamosi says there's too much money to be made- both in creating spyware and in stopping it. Is the end in sight for spyware, or will we continue to battle this as long as we have the Internet?
Your PC needs a firewall
If you don't already have a reliable firewall installed on your PC, don't fear. Jason Parker picks his three favorite firewall apps. What's your favorite?


 
Weigh in on this week's hot topic:
What type of device do you currently use as a portable MP3 player?
(Please click on button to vote)

 Flash-based player (which one?)
 Hard drive-based player (which one?)
 PDA (which one?)
 Cell phone (which one?)
 Laptop (which one?)
 I don't need no stinkin' music 
    (why not?)

 I plan on getting one soon 
    (which one? how soon?)

 I don't plan to get one (why not?)
Last week's poll results 
Which is better, digital cable or satellite?
What's next?
Want to sound off on a future hot topic? Dive into some of our community hotspots. Or if you have a special topic in mind, e-mail us.
CNET Editors' Blogs
Cell phones vs. MP3s
Wi-Fi Buying Guide
Top 10 downloads
Silly upgrades
Hot Houses

Hot Products
Along with discussing portable MP3 players, CNET members had plenty of new tech products to talk about this week.

Dell Latitude X1
CNET member bluenote69 says:
"This is my first Dell, and I am very impressed with the quality. The laptop feels really solid (not cheap like so many people say). The screen is nice and bright, and the resolution makes it so there is lots of usable space." (read more)
Read all user opinions | Compare prices

Nextel i860
CNET member JunFan08 says:
"The i860 is definitely the best phone that Nextel has introduced so far. Its compact and relatively lightweight design, coupled with a sleek color scheme and innovative hinge flip, make it fun and modern-looking." (read more)
Read all user opinions | Compare prices

Nikon Coolpix S1
CNET member t_chan123 says:
"'User friendly' is the key phrase to describe this camera. It is fantasically easy to use and so intuitive that I didn't even need to read the user manual. The picture quality is superb - the Nikon lens and folded optics technology really work well for Nikon here." (read more)
See all user opinions | Compare prices


This week on CNET 
We've redesigned our charts!
We've redesigned our charts!
Our charts reveal which phones create the most radiation. And now, they're easier to read. Read more



The e-mail address for your CNET Community newsletter is test.tester@cnet.com. Click here to manage your newsletters, including this one.

If you no longer wish to receive this newsletter, please unsubscribe.

CNET newsletters are now RSS friendly Check out our Newsletter RSS feeds

Privacy statement
CNET Networks takes your privacy seriously. Because we gather certain types of information about our users, we want you to clearly understand the terms and conditions surrounding the collection and use of this information. We encourage you to review our privacy policy.

Copyright 2005 CNET Networks, Inc. All rights reserved.
CNET Networks, Inc.
235 Second Street
San Francisco, CA 94105
U.S.A.