CNET Community help and how-to weekly newsletter
July 14, 2006
Dear CNET members,
Happy Friday, folks! For this week's topic, we have a situation concerning CNET member San's external hard drive that's not being recognized by his computer. As with all hardware problems, there are numerous possible causes that could result in this issue, ranging from a physically bad drive to a missing driver. So for starters, here's this week's winning answer by Dana, but if that solution doesn't lead you to any success, please check out the other possibilities in the honorable mentions and other advice from our members. My sneaking suspicion is that your unrecognized external hard drive is similar to a topic that we covered a few weeks back when a member's USB flash drive went MIA when plugged in--so here is that newsletter edition to go on for more info. Anyway, I wish you the best of luck San, and I have my fingers crossed that your hard drive really isn't just toast. If any of you have experienced a similar situation with your external hard drive and solved the issue, please join us in this week's discussion thread. Have a great weekend!

(Just a friendly reminder to new subscribers to this newsletter: We have an archive of our past Community newsletters, which cover many technical topics. So give it a try, because I see a lot of questions that have previously been covered by our community members.)

Cheers!
Lee Koo
Manager, CNET community


Got suggestions? Send me an e-mail:
messageboards@cnet.com
Member Question of the Week
Q I have a Dell Dimension XPS running at 750MHz, with 512MB of RAM and a 37GB SATA hard drive. I have Windows XP and use a LaCie 80GB external hard drive for storage. I have antivirus and antispyware apps and a firewall that I update regularly. The computer became very sluggish, and I decided to reformat the hard drive. I was advised to pull the USB 2.0 cable of the external hard drive from the computer before reformatting, which I did. After the reformatting process, the computer runs fine. However, it does not recognize the LaCie external hard drive, yet the button indicating power is on and lighted, and I can feel the drive spinning. I tried the external hard drive on different computers, and again it is not recognized. My questions are:
1. What went so wrong?
2. Can this be avoided in the future?
3. How can I retrieve the data on that external drive?
I hope somebody can help. Thank you.
Submitted by: San L.

Hi, San, I am not really sure where to start here because I am a little confused about your setup here. It seems you made a great choice to keep Windows and your data on separate drives. Your primary hard drive is a really fast SATA Raptor drive, which is great, but I would never use an external hard drive for general everyday data storage. Many will probably disagree with what I have to say, but external hard drives should really be used only for temporary backup. I would never suggest using an external hard drive as your only copy of your data or for regular everyday use. There are several reasons for this:
1. External hard drives are generally slower than internal drives.
2. Many of them come preformatted with Fat32, so you are limited to files no larger then 4GB.
3. They are more likely to fail because they are normally subjected to a greater likelihood of accidental bumping or dropping.
4. Many external drive enclosures are not properly cooled for continuous usage and this leads to premature failure.
5. You often have no idea what brand of hard drive is actually inside the enclosure.
Submitted by: Dana H. of Wayland, Massachusetts
Please click the following links for this week's:
Honorable mentions
Other advice from our members
For Dana's efforts, we're sending him his choice of any Help.com Learning CD.
Community Buzz
Each week we take a look at topics discussed in the forums.
Best regards and enjoy!
Advice for a buying a new PC
CNET member luckylady_63 is looking to purchase a new computer. Well, as she soon found out, it can be a task and a half to comprehend, especially if you have no clue as to what to get--from brands to hardware. In these discussions, people have taken the first step to share their experiences in buying a computer. So before you hit the stores, read on. If you have some recommendations for our member, drop on in and share it with us.
More from Desktops forum

Beware of imageshack.com?
Many of our forum users use imageshack.com (a free image hosting site) to upload pictures/screenshots of a computer problem and share with the rest of community. However, one CNET member, Bugbatter, found some blogs on the Internet saying to beware of this company which may be spewing out Trojans when others click a link to an image from them. If you use imageshack.com and have directly experienced this, please inform us about it in this discussion. It would great to find out if this is true or not.
More from Viruses & security alerts forum

Making an old PC run faster
CNET member ADESTRO has an old workhorse computer, and he would like to get some advice on how to speed it up without having to spend much money to do so. If you find yourself in the same situation, see what advice our members are offering to get his slowpoke computer up to speed. If you have some advice on this topic, share them with us in this discussion.
More from Desktops forum

Mac nugget: Popular Mac discussions
  • Mac disk error: best solution?
  • Ad-aware for Mac?
  • Apple Boot Camp resource and video games compatibility list


  • More from the Mac OS forum

    Check out next week's question:
    Q Hi, I wonder if someone can suggest a solution. My computer (CUP P4, 2.39GHz speed, OS Win XP Home + Service Pack 2, aystem RAM 1GB) makes a, relatively speaking, loud noise, which can only be compared to the muffled noise one hears sitting in an aeroplane getting ready to take off. It goes on for a good 15 minutes' duration though not at a consistent pitch. Then it dies down and eventually becomes normal. I only noticed it recently since I installed a home network with a router connected to it by Ethernet connection. Although it will be a rash judgment to consider it the proven reason for the trouble. My network works great I have two computers connected to this computer wirelessly (i.e., three computers on the network, only this one hardwire connected). Any suggestions and help will be appreciated.
    --Submitted by: Shafiq K. of the United Kingdom
    If you have the answer,
    e-mail us at messageboards@cnet.com.
    If we choose your response, you'll get a
    free Help.com CD.
    Click here for Q&A submission guidelines and check out our previous Help & How-to newsletters here.
    Have a question?
    E-mail us on one of our upcoming topics:
    • Multimedia
    • Internet Security
    • Digital Cameras
    • PC Upgrading
    • PC Troubleshooting
    • Digital Music
    Need help right away? Don't wait for us, come and join our lively community forums for all the tech help and how-tos.
    What do you use your external hard drive for?
    (Please click on button to vote)

     Backing up files (tell us more)
     Additional storage space (tell us more)
     Organizing media files (tell us more)
     As a shared storage drive (tell us more)
     Locking up important files (tell us more)
     Other (please explain)
     I don't have an external drive
    Member Profile of the Week
      User name: romeyinfc
      Location: Fort Collins, Colorado
      Member since: June 01, 2006
    About me: I've drifted my way to a nontraditional (a nice way of saying extended-year plan) Computer Information... (read more)
    Each week we feature a CNET member who contributes to our community. Fill out your profile to get a chance to be featured in our newsletter and win a CNET t-shirt!
    Simple question, simple answer
    Help your fellow members
    The e-mail address for your CNET Community newsletter is test.tester@cnet.com. Click here to manage your newsletters, including this one.

    If you no longer wish to receive this newsletter, please unsubscribe.

    Privacy statement
    CNET Networks takes your privacy seriously. Because we gather certain types of information about our users, we want you to clearly understand the terms and conditions surrounding the collection and use of this information. We encourage you to review our privacy policy.

    Copyright 2006 CNET Networks, Inc. All rights reserved.
    CNET Networks, Inc.
    235 Second Street
    San Francisco, CA 94105
    U.S.A.