CNET Community Hot Topics weekly newsletter
December 6, 2005
Dear CNET members,
OK, here's a scenario for you: you're at local retailer. After a long conversation with a helpful salesperson, you've made the decision to buy the product. You're ready to check out when suddenly the salesperson blindsides you with the pitch, "Would you like the extended warranty with that?" Your first reaction is to say no, but the salesperson starts to lay on the spiel about the benefits and the things that could go wrong with the product. You start frantically try to rationalize, but because you're on the spot, you accept. Then you go home and think: "Did I make the right decision to buy that extended warranty?" Does this sound familiar to you? Well, you're not alone. I've been in that situation plenty of times in the past, and I can remember only one instance where my extended warranty paid off. The rest weren't well-thought-out decisions. So do you think extended warranties are worth the extra protection, or are they simply a rip-off? Got a good or bad extended warranty story to share with us? Before you take on TalkBack to tell us your story, read editor Tom Merritt's article, "Should you pay for an extended warranty?" to get the real deal on extended warranties and tell us what you think. We're listening.

Cheers!
Lee Koo
Manager, CNET community


Got suggestions? Send us an e-mail:
messageboards@cnet.com
This week's hot topic:
Are extended warranties really worth it?
When buying consumer electronics, is it worth shelling out extra for an extended warranty? That's the question Tom Merritt asked in his latest The Real Deal column, and many of you offered some interesting insights.

It's just not worth it
A true gadget lover, CNET member fire1fl never buys an extended warranty for a variety of reasons. He also urges us to consider the "life cycle" of what we're buying--if it's something that we'll likely want to replace in a couple years, extended warranties hold less value.
Read fire1fl's full post in CNET TalkBack

A must for mobile devices
When it comes to laptops and handhelds, many of you shared experiences that show how an extended warranty can be a real lifesaver. CNET member Jonathanrayce has made it through multiple drive crashes, faulty networking, and broken cooling systems without breaking the bank--all thanks to his extended warranty.
Read Jonathanrayce's post in CNET TalkBack

All the way to the bank
CNET member rholley13 has an innovative solution. Take the money you would spend on any extended warranty, and put it in the bank instead. Even if you end up paying for repairs, odds are you'll still end up ahead.
Read rholley13's full post in CNET TalkBack

Speak Up!
Do you think an extended warranty is a good idea? Read "Should you pay for an extended warranty?" and and share your experiences in the TalkBack section.
CNET warranty resources:
Extended warranty for your HDTV:
  worth the price?

  From The Screening Room

Tech Nightmares: Customer service
  From CNET Reviews

Quick Hits
Here are some interesting comments you've recently submitted on CNET. Read up and talk about it.

Robert Vamosi's Security Watch
Is your PC a drug mule?
Today, criminals are making more money from cybercrime than from drug-related crime. But before you ask what's being done about that, maybe you should see what's running inside your own computer. Will law enforcement ever get the upper hand on cybercrime? Is it folly to think so?
Driving It
Navigation systems: why they're
lame, what they need

He's said it before, and he'll say it again: In-car navigation systems are a joke. CNET editor at large Brian Cooley thinks they're not that smart, and some of the features are just useless. Yet, he's not giving up hope. Read on to see which three technologies have him excited for the future of in-car navigation. Do you think today's in-car nav systems are a joke? What would you do
to improve them?
Point and Shout
What's your most useful digital
photography tip?

We've all experienced the joys, the frustrations, and that magical moment when a workaround solution to a particular problem jolts you. Here's a chance to share your brilliance with fellow readers and learn a bit from them on
digital photography.


 
Weigh in on this week's hot topic:
Are extended warranties worth it?
(Please click on button to vote)

 Yes, I always buy them (tell us why)
 No, they’re a rip-off! (please explain)
 It depends on the price of the item
    (for example?)
 What's a warranty? (you're in trouble)
 I should’ve gotten one for my boss,
    he's malfunctioning!
Last week's poll results 
What are you least looking forward to
this holiday season?
What's next?
Want to sound off on a future hot topic? Dive into some of our community hotspots. Or if you have a special topic in mind, e-mail us.
Editors' favorite laptops
First Xbox 360 lawsuit
MP3 players for
  under $50
eBay buying tips
Best MP3 phones
Gear for a
  great date

CNET Deal Exchange
Check out these special deals from our CNET certified merchants.

TomTom GO 300
The TomTom GO 300 delivers lightning-fast route calculations, colorful maps, and concise audible driving directions. It's $549 after a $50 rebate at Datavision Computer Video.
Read More


Samsung YEPP YP-F1X
The Digital Wear MP3 player can store up to 120 songs and plays for 10 hours, so you'll have music no matter where or how far you go. It's $99 plus free shipping at BestBuy.com. Read More

Epson Stylus Photo R800 Printer
This excellent printer cedes its Editors' Choice crown to the Canon iP8500 but remains a great choice for photo enthusiasts: $334 after a $50 rebate at Tiger Direct. Read More

Microsoft Digital Image Pro 10
Ideal software utility for turning dull photos into brilliantly creative projects: $63 after a $40 rebate at Atomic Park. Read More


This week on CNET 
CNET's camera phone image gallery
Compare camera phone pics
Use our tool to see side-by-side shots taken by nearly all the camera phones you can buy.
Read more

CNET's My Products
My Products holiday wish lists
Your holiday wish list is well rounded by now, but how's Grandma going to easily differentiate between the Xbox 360 bundle (which you want) and the Core System (which you don't)? Make it easy by putting the exact gifts you want on your new My Products: Want It list. Then she can just click and buy! Create your list now

CNET's free newsletters

The latest news, reviews,
and features on cameras
and camcorders.
Delivered Mondays
 
Sign up now


The e-mail address for your CNET Community newsletter is test.tester@cnet.com. Click here to manage your newsletters, including this one.

If you no longer wish to receive this newsletter, please unsubscribe.

CNET newsletters are now RSS friendly Check out our Newsletter RSS feeds

Privacy statement
CNET Networks takes your privacy seriously. Because we gather certain types of information about our users, we want you to clearly understand the terms and conditions surrounding the collection and use of this information. We encourage you to review our privacy policy.

Copyright 2005 CNET Networks, Inc. All rights reserved.
CNET Networks, Inc.
235 Second Street
San Francisco, CA 94105
U.S.A.